I'm a mainstream maths teacher, and I'm off work today, taking part in the public sector strike on pay and conditions, specifically centred on pensions cuts. I feel that simply taking the day off and staying silent isn't doing my bit, so here is my main reason for taking part:
Teaching, as a job, a career, is a demanding one, if you're going to do it right. Schools need the best candidates with the best backgrounds and the best experience if they're going to get the best out of the students under their care. In this at least, the current government seems to agree with us, even if I don't entirely agree that the 'best' candidates for a teaching role are necessarily the ones with the highest degree classification (as seems to be the feeling from those on high).
Mathematics and science as subjects are currently under-subscribed in terms of teaching staff. This is great news for maths and science teachers as it means that they essentially have their pick of the jobs as many schools are struggling to fill vacancies in these areas. This means, however, that it is even more important that decent candidates with specialisms in these disciplines are attracted into the career. This, too, seems to be agreed by our representatives in government, with many of the initiatives in the link above directed specifically at graduates in the sciences.
Where agreement falls down, however, seems to be in the pay, working conditions and pensions department. Cutting pay*, reducing pension entitlements and increasing workload sends out entirely the wrong message. The message that is being sent out is one that teachers are little more than a drain on society, that we are relatively unimportant, and that the work we do doesn't require half the skills and experience that are suggested by the measures supposedly being introduced to lure top graduates into the profession in the first place.
While there are a number of factors behind my decision to join in with strike action, this is easily the peak of the pile: schools need the best quality candidates to ensure that our society's children get the best from their education, yet society itself is doing its level best on a daily basis to degrade teaching from a legitimate career option to a last-chance desperate grab at a career when all else fails.
Every time you complain about teachers; their massive holidays, their ludicrously high pay, their ridiculously short working hours, you are pandering to this frankly idiotic misunderstanding of what the career of teaching actually involves. If you are strong in your anti-teacher beliefs, please consider where you have acquired them: if they have come from anywhere other than your own, personal, adult experience, then I would encourage you to get in touch with a mainstream school local to you and try volunteering to teach for just one day. If it really is that easy, and you'd be happy to do the work for the money and benefits that are being offered, then apply for a training course, especially if you have a background in maths or science.
With society's continual and unfounded teacher-bashing, governments find it much easier to take liberties with our pay and conditions, and the whole shebang becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy: you tell us we're rubbish and reduce pay and pensions and increase workload accordingly, so the best current teachers leave and the best new candidates take their skills elsewhere, so the standard drops, so you tell us we're even worse, and the government panders to that, dropping pay, reducing pensions and increasing workload, so more people leave (or never sign up in the first place) and the standard continues to fall.
So yes, that's largely why I'm striking. Apologies for any ranty bits. As always, I'm happy to discuss any sensible comments anybody makes, but I'm likely to either ignore or respond witheringly to any unfounded hyperbole (it's unfortunate that it's so common as to be worth mentioning when entering into a discussion about teaching...) so please, please make sure your comments are appropriate.
P.S: If you're a teacher, please fill in this poll about whether or not you're striking! Your reasons and thoughts either way would be much appreciated, too.
* We've had a pay freeze for the last two years. With inflation still positive, this means that although our pay essentially stays the same (numerically), the value of that number decreases year on year.
*drives by, honks horn, raises supportive fist*
ReplyDeleteThanks for your support!
ReplyDeleteconsider yourself agreed with. I know an NQT who says that day to day, teaching is harder thna being on deployment, and as he is ex RAF himself he should know!
ReplyDeleteIt will be interesting to see the impact of today.
We've had this discussion before Tom! I agree with just about everything you say. i believe that teachers are under-valued; that they job is more difficult than I or others know; that they didn't cause the deficit; that those who caused it should be held responsible for it; that financial institutions should be better regulated etc etc etc.
ReplyDeleteI can never agree though with this particular strike. We are where we are and everyone unfortunately is having to take some pain. I will add at this stage that we should all expect more. We have not plumbed the depths yet and it is going to get worse before it gets better. You wait until a major bank goes bust on the back of a country in the Euro zone defaulting. Then you'll see some very unpleasant (but totally necessary) fiscal strategy by the UK Government.
Pensions "promises" to the Public Sector cannot be afforded anymore. Full stop. End of. This was recognised in the Private Sector many years ago and we've all had to pay more and work longer. Why are Public Sector workers any different?
I really hope the Union Barons get off their politically motivated high horses, see sense and get this resolved. I've nothing against talking. Negotiate away! But no strikes should take place where the whole country and ecomony (which is fragile enough) is affected.
But Tom, You're pension will cost you more. And you will work longer. Strike or not. Believe me.
Grant:
ReplyDeleteI know. I don't think anyone seriously believes that we're going to get away without any cuts. What's being protested is the fact that cutting teacher pensions and pay, extending working life and increasing workload is often the first port of call.
Also what's being protested is the fact that the government has sidestepped the official teaching pay and conditions review body on numerous occasions in order to get these things in motion.
One reason why I'm doing my tiny bit is that whilst we're all going to suffer cuts and degradation of quality of life, those who sit back and take it are going to suffer greater cuts. I don't want that; I don't think that what I'm doing is as unimportant as many people would like to tell me, and I would like some recognition for doing what I do in the form of not having my pay cut and my working conditions worsened so that some other areas of government can continue to get their free pensions for a little bit longer.